Bufo’s AI What If #2: Casablanca

This is the second in a series where I present a What If pop culture scenario to a text-generatng artficial intelligence (software that writes like people write) and we discuss it. This time, as in the last one, I’m chatting with Open.AI’s ChatGPT. I do this for two main reasons: one is that I’m fascinated with the technology, and want to see what it can do. Second, I genuinely enjoy these types of discussions with humans. I’m finding that I also enjoy them with AI!

SPOILER ALERT FOR CASABLANCA

I’m about to reproduce our dicsussion about the movie Casablanca. It will necessarily have spoilers for the movie. If you haven’t seen it yet, you may want to watch it before you read the below.

Here’s the conversation. ChatGPT’s comments will be in italics.

Bufo: Good morning! I had fun with you recently discussing what would have happened if Dorothy’s house had fall(en) on Glinda instead of on the Wicked Witch of the East in the Wizard of Oz.

Let’s try another one: what do you think would have happened if Rick in Casablanca decided to use the Letters of Transit to escape with Ilsa, so he and Ilsa could be together and he could personally keep her safe?

ChatGPT: Good morning! It’s great to chat with you again, and I’m glad you enjoyed our last discussion.

As for your new question, if Rick had decided to use the Letters of Transit to escape with Ilsa, a number of possible outcomes could have resulted.

Firstly, it’s important to note that the Letters of Transit were a fictional plot device created for the film, as they do not actually exist in reality. However, assuming that they did exist in the context of the story, and that Rick was able to use them to leave Casablanca with Ilsa, here are some potential scenarios:

1. Rick and Ilsa escape successfully: If Rick and Ilsa were able to leave Casablanca with the Letters of Transit, they could potentially start a new life together outside of the reach of the Nazis. However, it’s possible that they would face challenges and dangers in their new life, as the war was still ongoing and the Nazis were expanding their control across Europe.
2. Rick is caught and arrested: If Rick was caught trying to use the Letters of Transit to leave Casablanca with Ilsa, he could be arrested by the authorities and potentially face a lengthy prison sentence or even execution for his actions. This would likely have devastating consequences for Ilsa as well, as she would be left alone in Casablanca without Rick to protect her.
3. Rick is killed while trying to escape: It’s possible that Rick could be killed while attempting to leave Casablanca with Ilsa using the Letters of Transit. This would be a tragic outcome, as it would mean that Rick would never be able to see Ilsa again, and she would be left alone and vulnerable in a dangerous city.
4. Rick and Ilsa are caught and deported back to Casablanca: If Rick and Ilsa were caught trying to use the Letters of Transit, they could be deported back to Casablanca, where they would likely face harsh consequences for their attempted escape. This could include imprisonment, execution, or even being turned over to the Nazis.

In any case, it’s difficult to say for sure what would happen if Rick had decided to use the Letters of Transit to escape with Ilsa. The outcome would depend on a number of factors, including whether or not they were successful in their attempt, how they were caught (if they were caught), and what the authorities decided to do with them. However, it’s clear that their decision would have significant consequences for their lives and the lives of those around them.

Bufo: Interesting! I appreciate the different scenarios you’ve presented.

If Rick was caught with the Letters of Transit, do you think his relationship with Renault might have helped him avoid serious consequences?

ChatGPT: It’s possible that Rick’s relationship with Renault could have helped him avoid serious consequences if he was caught with the Letters of Transit. Throughout the film, Rick and Renault have a complicated relationship that involves a mix of cooperation, rivalry, and mutual respect. While Renault is technically an ally of the Vichy French government and therefore obligated to enforce their laws, he is also portrayed as a pragmatic and opportunistic figure who is willing to bend the rules when it suits him.

If Rick was caught with the Letters of Transit, it’s possible that he could have appealed to Renault’s sense of pragmatism and convinced him to look the other way. For example, Rick could argue that his escape with Ilsa would have no impact on the outcome of the war, and that allowing them to leave would actually be in the best interest of both the French and the Germans, as it would reduce the risk of violence or unrest in Casablanca.

Alternatively, Renault could use the situation to his advantage and negotiate a deal with Rick in exchange for his freedom. This could involve anything from financial gain to political leverage or personal favors.

However, it’s important to remember that Renault is ultimately a complex and unpredictable character, and his actions are influenced by a variety of factors, including his personal beliefs, political allegiances, and desire for power and status. As such, it’s difficult to say for sure how he would have acted in this hypothetical scenario.

Bufo: That’s a good point, Renault is complex. I do think he genuinely likes Rick, although you are right that he might sacrifice Rick if it was for his own personal safety.

So, let’s say that after Laszlo is arrested, Rick doesn’t intervene to get him released. In that scenario, it seems like Renault was okay with Rick taking Ilsa and leaving Casablanca.

Would Ilsa go willingly with Rick, leaving her husband behind in jail? Do you think she might have been manipulating Rick talking about their old relationship, when she really wanted to get the letters of transit for herself and Victor?

ChatGPT: If Rick didn’t intervene to get Laszlo released and Renault allowed Rick to leave with Ilsa, it’s difficult to say for sure whether Ilsa would go willingly with Rick or if she had other motivations.

On the one hand, it’s possible that Ilsa might have been genuinely conflicted about her feelings for Rick and her loyalty to Laszlo, and that she might have decided to leave with Rick as a result. After all, the film portrays Ilsa as a complex and nuanced character with her own desires and motivations, and it’s clear that she still has feelings for Rick even if she is committed to Laszlo.

On the other hand, it’s also possible that Ilsa might have been manipulating Rick in order to obtain the Letters of Transit for herself and Laszlo. Throughout the film, Ilsa is portrayed as a strong and intelligent character who is capable of manipulating others to get what she wants. It’s possible that she might have played up her feelings for Rick in order to convince him to help her and Laszlo escape, even if she didn’t actually intend to leave with Rick in the end.

Ultimately, it’s difficult to say for sure what Ilsa’s true motivations would have been in this scenario. However, regardless of whether she was genuinely conflicted or manipulating Rick, it’s clear that the decision to leave with Rick would have had significant consequences for her relationship with Laszlo and for the outcome of the war.

Bufo: Oh, fascinating! What impact do you think it would have had on the actual outcome of the war? Was Laszlo that important to the Czech resistance? Weren’t Victor & Ilsa trying to get to America? If the alternatives are that he is free in America or in custody in Europe, would it make that much of a difference to the outcome of World War II?

ChatGPT: It’s true that Laszlo’s individual fate might not have had a significant impact on the actual outcome of the war, as the Czech resistance was only one small part of the larger conflict. However, the symbolic value of Laszlo’s escape and his ability to continue fighting against the Nazis would have been important for morale and propaganda purposes.

In the context of the film, Laszlo is portrayed as a heroic figure who has been leading the resistance movement against the Nazis in Czechoslovakia. His escape and continued leadership would have been a powerful symbol of resistance and hope for those fighting against the Nazi regime.

Additionally, it’s worth noting that Ilsa and Laszlo were trying to get to America not just for their own safety, but also to continue their fight against the Nazis from a position of greater influence and resources. If they were able to escape Casablanca with the Letters of Transit and make it to America, they could potentially have played a greater role in the war effort and made a significant impact on its outcome.

Overall, while the fate of one individual might not have had a significant impact on the outcome of the war as a whole, the symbolic and strategic value of Laszlo’s escape would have been important for the morale and success of the resistance movement.

Bufo: You make excellent points! I hadn’t thought enough about the morale value, and that is important.

Anything else you’d like to speculate about Casablanca before we end this chat?

One interesting aspect of Casablanca that is often discussed is the way in which the film portrays the complicated nature of personal relationships and political allegiances during wartime.

Throughout the film, the characters are forced to make difficult choices between their personal desires and their commitment to the greater good. Rick must choose between his love for Ilsa and his duty to help Laszlo escape, while Ilsa must decide where her loyalties lie and whether she is willing to sacrifice her own happiness for the sake of the war effort.

This theme of conflicting loyalties is particularly relevant in the context of World War II, as many people were forced to make difficult choices and sacrifices in order to fight against fascism and preserve their values and way of life.

Overall, Casablanca is a timeless film that continues to resonate with audiences today, in part because of its exploration of these complex themes and its portrayal of the human experience during a time of great conflict and upheaval.

Bufo: True: I think that great stories usually resonate with people because of the choices characters make, and how the audience can relate those choices to their own lives (or lives they might have).

Thanks again for a thoughtful discussion! I look forward to our next “What if?”!

ChatGPT: You’re welcome, it was a pleasure discussing Casablanca with you! I’m always here if you have any other questions or want to explore more “What if?” scenarios in the future. Have a great day!

I was really impressed with this one! It certainly felt like I was discussing the movie with another (human) fan.

I was a bit surprised when I asked it if it would “like” to speculate more, it didn’t tell me that it was a language AI & didn’t have likes and dislikes: it answered it like a human would.

I also honestly felt it understood the implications of Victor getting to America better than I did! I’ve watched Casablanca many times, but it has been years. I’ve always been more focused on Rick, Ilsa, Sam, & the supporting characters than Victor’s story.

Oh, and it was funny: I read part of it to my Significant Other who suggested that it was actually a human pretendng to be an AI (like The Mechanical Turk chess playing “automaton” over a hundred years ago). Honestly, it’s just too fast! It types these answers in the matter of a few seconds.

I’m interested to know what you think! You can comment on this post, but the best thing is probably to reach out to me on Twitter:

If there’s a “What if” you’d llike me to discuss with AI (just pop culture, please, nothing political or personal, & let’s keep it to 2020 or earlier), let me know! Obviously, I can only do questions where I know the topic well enough to discuss it intelligently.

I hope you enjoy these and find them interesting!

Join thousands of readers and try the free The Measured Circle magazine at Flipboard!

All aboard our The Measured Circle’s Geek Time Trip at The History Project (AKA Enwoven)! Join the TMCGTT Timeblazers!

Bufo’s Alexa Skills

This post by Bufo Calvin originally appeared in the The Measured Circle blog. To support this or other organizations, begin your Amazon shopping from a link on their sites: Amazon.com (Smile.Amazon.com)